Sign the Petition
Dear Governor DeSantis:
Most of this letter’s signatories aren’t eligible to vote, and if they are, they likely supported another candidate for governor. But, it’s also fair to say that many of us have been pleasantly surprised by some of your actions since taking office. From your environmental reforms to your proposal to expand teacher salaries, your policies have already created measurable improvements in the lives of Floridians.
While the education system will certainly benefit from changes to teacher pay, another one of your plans may seriously threaten the success of Florida’s students. Depriving public schools of millions of dollars in favor of state spending on school choice vouchers would harm the vast majority of schoolchildren—including those who end up being granted the scholarships to attend private schools.
Despite the prevailing stereotype of private schools as superior learning environments to public schools, there is “scant evidence” that this is the case. Although there are many private schools that offer great educational opportunities, these schools are outnumbered by those that relish in mediocrity.
Their for-profit models, whereby owners can pocket funding instead of investing in their students, coupled with their shocking lack of regulation means private schools are often unacceptably poor in providing knowledge and resources to students. That includes some schools that currently participate in Florida’s existing private school voucher system.
Unlike public schools, private schools in Florida are not required to follow the state’s academic standards, distribute standardized tests, hire teachers with bachelor’s degrees and state certification, publicize budgets, report graduation rates, or meet school building codes. They are, however, allowed to infuse curriculum with religious dogma and political opinion, which many schools take advantage of to teach false or biased material to impressionable children.
Of about 2,000 private schools participating in Florida’s voucher program, just 27 were inspected in 2015. Only four met the minimum requirements to receive scholarships.
Some schools hire teachers with criminal convictions, mislead parents about programs for special needs students, or falsify results of safety inspections and continue to receive money from vouchers. The Orlando Sentinel reports that others “disparage religions other than Protestant Christianity and cultures other than those descended from white Europeans,” which is even more alarming considering that 60 percent of voucher recipients are black or Hispanic.
In private schools, some students are taught that humans lived with dinosaurs, that the civil rights movement was an encroachment on the “harmony” that existed between blacks and whites by “power-hungry individuals,” or that communism is something to be aspired to.
Instead of our school’s dance recitals, philharmonic concerts, and sports programs, this is what taxpayer money would ultimately support.
While some may argue that these are isolated incidents, no child should ever have such an atrocious educational experience. And sadly, underachieving private schools appear to be the norm.
In Louisiana, a study of students participating in a voucher program found that public elementary schoolers who transferred to private schools showed drastic dips in both reading and math comprehension. Kids who started at the fiftieth percentile in math found themselves at the twenty-sixth percentile one year later.
A Department of Education study examining a voucher program in Washington, D.C. found similar results. Those who qualified for the vouchers but remained in public schools performed significantly better than their private school peers in math.
A full examination of data from voucher programs by Stanford University Professor of Education Martin Carnoy is consistent with the findings from these two studies: Private school vouchers do not improve students’ education.
Then why push for them? The basic reasoning is that the more freedom parents have to decide for their children, the better. But when a parent’s choice comes down to an inadequate private school and an underfunded public school, that freedom is worthless. And when a child’s education is placed in the hands of someone who thinks dinosaurs lived with humans, their intellect and opportunity may never recover.
In defending your support for school choice scholarships, you have pointed to the number of minority students who make use of them. But, if you really want to serve disadvantaged minorities and low-income students, taking money from public schools is not the way to do it. Research has shown that with higher public education funding, poor students are more likely to graduate high school and earn higher salaries afterwards.
Already, students deal with a severe shortage in state backing for public education, and the plan you put forward to raid the budget for private school vouchers would take more than $110 million from our public schools.
Florida’s 2.8 million public school students deserve better. They deserve better than a state ranking of forty-fourth for per-pupil spending in public schools. They deserve better than to see their friends whisked off to private schools with money that could have bought them a new computer. Or a textbook. Or a classroom. Or a meal.
For some students, local public schools are their only options, even if they were to be offered vouchers for private schools. Transportation obstacles, enrollment issues, and information barriers prevent many parents from finding feasible alternatives to the nearest public school.
If you still want to guarantee parents’ ability to send their children to whichever subpar school they desire, fine. We realize that it may be difficult to renege on a campaign promise or disappoint your base.
We ask, instead, for a compromise. We refuse to believe that you are anything less than a man who wants only the best for Florida’s children. Your time in Congress shows your willingness to take a principled stand despite personal costs, whether it be your support for the No Budget/No Pay Act or your refusal to accept a Congressional pension and health insurance plan.
Florida is the state with the fourth highest GDP, yet it spends less than almost every other state on public education for each student. We can afford to do more for the children who will one day lead our nation.
For every taxpayer dollar spent on private school vouchers, we propose that the same amount be added to the budget to fund Florida’s public schools. This way, public schools and their students can receive the resources they desperately need, and Betsy DeVos can continue heaping praise on Florida’s education system.
We hope that you listen and do what’s right for the next generation of Floridians, as we hope your children—Mason and Madison—will continue to shine as they follow in their father’s footsteps.
Sincerely,
Jarom Gordon
Jassem Abdallah
Sara Abdo
Isabella Adia
Kevin Ahern
Kyle Ahern
Aelly Alwardi
Christopher Anthony
Samarah Antoine
Brendan Arp
Emma Artero
Hannah Baldwin
Lexis Barbieri
Sasha A. Bass
Vanessa Benitz
Gina Bernstein
Ainhoa Bezerra
Rebecca Boss
Krista Brochu
Garfield Govanny Brown
Eden Brown
Jaime Brustein
Christian C.
Katelynn Carroll
Eliza Cave
Mailon Cedeno
Nirmit Chandan
Kavyasree Chigurupati
Alice Chong
Natalie Cohen
Megan Conrad
Ashley Cozad
Joseph Cuenco
Sophia Dawson
Sophy DeMoya
William Dhana
Rachel Dippolito
Connor Ehrich
Jonathan Estilien
Amanda Ferber
Cade Ferguson
Sebastian Fernandez
Priscila Fernandez
Corey G.
Cora Gancarz
Amanda Garcia
Hannah Gardner
Emma Garrett
Alissa Gary
Annemarie Gerlach
Annick Gilles
Cassie Glover
Shelby Godfrey
Kailee Goldstein
Adam Goldstick
Valentina Gomez
Julia Gonnello
Cameron Gordon
Christian Gordon
Julia Guerrero
Jordan Haft
Grace Handel
Caleb Harris
Myca Harris
Sean Horan
Sophie Huber
Amina Idrisi
Jennifer Jia
Mike Johns
Haley Johnston
Brendan Jordan
Addie Joslin
Morgan Jourdin
Arman Khoshbin
Carsten Kjaerulff
Isabella Kjaerulff
Noelle Knowlton
Asha Kollannur
Joshua Kopit
Lindsay Kuperman
Anna Lackovic
Madison LaRocque
Michael Laurito
David Liu
Dorothy Lu
Natalie Macadar
Kassidy Maki
Raunak Manchanda
Sofia Manocchio
Kaia Martino
Naomi van Es Maury
Trey Mazza
Tommy McCabe
Emma McCue
Kylie McKenna
Katherine McNamara
Marisa Mellone
Sonya Mikolutskaya
Sasha Monaco
Jean Montesinos
Mackensey Moore
Jacob Moses
Asher Moss
Kyle Murphy
Anamaria Navarrete
Sylvia Ng
Maily Nguyen
Maxine Nguyen
Shina Nguyen
Stella Oaks
Shweta Pandit
Lauren Perez
Mariah Perez
Monica Perez
Michael Pincus
Jenelle Pollock
Jules Popiel
Isabella Ramirez
Rayne Ramlal
Emma Ratchford
Hannah Reynolds
Sophia Roberts
Carolina Robinson
Giovanna Romano
Gianna Romano-Hall
Drew S.
Karmelysa Sabin
Annabella Saccaro
Schneider Saintil
Bennett Samuels
Deven Seedial
Aviva Senzon
Megan Shah
Sonya Shokhina
Mark Shteyman
Shea Siben
Julia Sivco
Leah Sloan
Sasha Smith
Elena Snyder
Ariana Soodeen
Emma Soto
Jackson Spellman
Annika Stevens
Adrianna Suarez
Milan Tangirala
Angie Thari
Adrianna Tucciarone
Aneri Vakil
Leedia Valler
Barrett Vargas
Robby Vargas
Franco Vidal
Julia Villa
Maya Voorhees
James Walter
Daniela Walters
Miles Wang
Alexandra Watson
Derion Williams
Sydney Williams
Autumn Wong
George Wu
Hannah Xie
Madison Yan
Philip Ye
Sade Young
Sofia Zarazua
Skyler Zur